The term “comprehensive” denotes the inclusion and coverage of all dimensions of a subject and is semantically linked to the concept of completeness. However, for decades within the literature of urban planning, the fundamental inadequacy of the methodological logic of comprehensive plans in problem formulation and comprehensive solution-finding for the multi-dimensional development of the city has been the subject of extensive and fundamental critique.
By reducing the multi-dimensional problems of the city, this method diminishes urban development to purely physical issues such as land use, street networks, and construction regulations, while marginalizing the complex economic, social, institutional, historical, and cultural dimensions and relationships of the city. On the other hand, the comprehensive plan reduces the city to a disconnected set of zones, land uses, and technical regulations, failing to comprehend the reciprocal and dynamic relationships among its various layers.
Nevertheless, physical regulations are merely one of the tools for regulation and intervention in the urban planning process; in the physicalist approach of the comprehensive plan, physical regulation becomes the central axis of planning and the dominant logic for understanding problems and determining the direction of interventions.
This reductionism demonstrates that this method lacks the requisite methodological capacity for comprehensively identifying and explaining urban problems and for understanding the complex and reciprocal relationships among the city’s issues, elements, and zones.
From this perspective, the comprehensive plan faces a fundamental methodological contradiction: a method whose very title induces a sense of comprehensiveness in the public mind is incomplete and flawed in problem formulation; because it substitutes comprehensiveness in regulating the physical form of the city for comprehensiveness in understanding the complex economic, social, institutional, and spatial relationships and in guiding the urban development process.
| Rights and permissions | |
|
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |